Apollo 15: Mission, Achievements, and Controversies

The Apollo 15 was the fourth U.S. spacecraft to land on the Moon. And although the mission achieved its goals, it is also remembered for its hiccups and controversies.

Let’s review the good and the bad.

The Apollo 15 mission

Picture taken on the lunar surface. It shows Apollo 15's astronaut Jim Irwin saluting the American flag that stands next to him. In the background are the spacecraft and a mountain.
Astronaut Jim Irwin, from Apollo 15, salutes the U.S. flag during his last day on the Moon. August 1971. (Photo: NASA/Public domain)

The U.S. had already launched 24 spacecrafts into space and 3 of them had landed on the Moon’s surface. So this time, NASA turned things up a notch.

Apollo 15 was to stay longer on the Moon’s surface and to have a stronger scientific component than the previous missions.

The Apollo launched on July 26, 1971 with three astronauts on board and four goals to accomplish.

The first one was to explore the landing area of the Moon. It is called Hadley-Appenine and is a mountainous region full of craters and canyons.

Then, the astronauts were to set up scientific experiments on the Moon’s surface to learn more about both the Moon and the Earth. They even included one of Galileo’s experiments which would help understand the laws of physics better.

The third objective was an easy one. NASA redesigned the astronauts’ equipment, and the trio was to evaluate the changes.

And the final one, was to orbit the Moon conducting more experiments and taking pictures.

The astronauts achieved all the mission’s objectives and returned safely to Earth 12 days after they left, that is on August 7, 1971.

The Apollo 15 shuttle

A rocket launching. Fire comes out from the rocket's bottom as the big white rocket clears the tower next to it and makes a cloud of smoke.
Apollo 15 begins its spatial journey. July 26, 1971. (Photo: NASA/Pubic domain)

Although at first sight the shuttle looks like one big rocket, it is actually made up of several parts that get discarded during the journey. And only one small part, the tip, returns to Earth.

The first thing to go is the rocket itself, which is the largest part of the shuttle. It is only needed to launch from Earth, but once in space it is ejected.

Now two main parts remain: the Command/Service Module and the Lunar Module.

This handy video shows the parts of the shuttle.

They are attached when they travel to the Moon. But once there, the Command Module, called Endeavor, stays orbiting the Moon, while the Lunar Module Falcon, manned by two astronauts, detaches and makes its way to the lunar surface.

After three days on the surface, the Falcon lifts off and rejoins the orbiting Endeavor.

Once the three astronauts are back on the Endeavor, they discard the Lunar Module, which crashes against the Moon’s surface.

But they still have one more part to get rid off. When they are about to reenter Earth, the Endeavor splits in two, ejecting the Service Module. Only the Command Module, which is the tip of the original shuttle, reenters Earth’s atmosphere.

Read next: These Elon Musk Companies Are Propelling You Into the Future

The players

An official picture of the Apollo 15 crew. The three astronauts are wearing their suits and stand close together. Behind them is a white wall with a sign that reads: Apollo 15, Scott, Warden, Irwin.
The hotshot test pilots that flew the Apollo 15. From left to right: Dave Scott, Al Worden, and Jim Irwin. (Photo: NASA/Public domain)

Like in all the previous space missions, the three crew members had been Air Force pilots.

Lieut. Col Al Worden orbited the Moon in the Endeavor, while Colonels Dave Scott and Jim Irwin landed on the Moon to explore it.

David Scott

Dave was the commander of the Apollo 15 mission, aka the boss.

The Texan was born in 1932 in the military air base where his father was serving. And since he was a boy he wanted to be a pilot, just like his dad.

His swimming prowess won him a scholarship from the University of Michigan, where he studied Engineering. West Point, the prestigious military school, took notice of the young engineer with top grades and invited him to attend, fulfilling one of Dave’s dreams.

Then Dave became a test pilot for the U.S. Air Force and even did a stint as a fighter pilot in Europe during the Cold War.

After a while the 31-year-old hotshot applied to NASA’s space program -he had a masters in Aeronautics from MIT- and before being chosen as Apollo 15’s commander, Dave went to space twice. The first time with Neil Armstrong in the Gemini 8 (1966), and the second as the pilot of Apollo 9‘s Command Module (1969).

The Apollo 15 mission was his third time in space.

James Irwin

Jim dreamt of being the first person to walk on the Moon. Problem was, this was in 1942 and no one had done it yet. So when the 12-year-old shared his vision with his neighbors, they laughed at him, while his practical mom said he could not live on the Moon.

But Jim was not deterred.

In 1951 he got his bachelor degree in Naval Science from the US Naval Academy, which he followed with degrees in Aeronautical and Instrumentation Engineering. Then the Pittsburgh-native became a F-12 pilot and a test pilot for the Air Force and received several medals.

And in 1966 NASA recruited him.

Three years later he was in the support crew for Apollo 10 and in the backup crew for the Apollo 12, along with Dave Scott.

In 1971 Jim was the Lunar Module Pilot for the Apollo 15. The 41-year-old may not have been the first man to take a walk on the Moon, but he was the 8th.

Alfred Worden

Unlike his fellow crew members, Al fell into his career by chance.

All he knew when he was a child was that he did not want to keep working in his family’s farm in Michigan. With the help of his high-school principal, Al landed a free spot at coveted West Point.

He followed the normal military career path, ended up being a pilot, and eventually applied to the space program.

Al was part of the support crew of Apollo 9, and later on, along with both Dave and Jim, on the backup team for Apollo 12.

In 1971 the 39-year-old went to space for the first time as the Command Module’s pilot for Apollo 15. He is the one that orbited the Moon while his comrades landed on the Moon’s surface.

Geology training for the Apollo crew

Outdoors in the desert, with mountains in the background. In the foreground two men, wearing big white backpacks, examine the ground with an instrument. Behind them is some sort of car.
Irwin (L) and Scot (R) during their geology training in New Mexico. The lunar rover is in the background. (Photo: NASA/Public domain)

During the first space missions, NASA was just trying to actually get to space and the Moon -while scoring some points against its arch-enemy the USSR.

But with Apollo 15 the objectives had expanded. They realized they had an opportunity to do scientific experiments and to learn about the Moon’s history.

So during the 20 months that the three pilots trained for their mission, they also packed hundreds of hours of geology classes.

Their education was entrusted to Cal Tech’s geologist Leon Silver and to NASA’s geologist Farouk El-Baz. They taught the pilots to describe the landscape and recognize different types of rocks. They also took them on field trips once a month to places like Hawaii, California’s desert, New Mexico, and NASA’s own backyard, the Kennedy Center in Florida.

By the end of the program, commander Dave Scott had taken quite a liking to it and proudly considered himself an amateur geologist.

The intense NASA training took its toll on two marriages, though. The Irwins made it through, but the Wordens divorced before the mission.

New gadgets for the Apollo 15

For the Apollo 15 mission, NASA redesigned the space suits, the ‘backpacks’, and a built a nifty lunar vehicle.

The Moon suits: The zipper was changed from an up-down zipper to one that went diagonally from hip to shoulder. That increased the range of motion of the legs, and diminished both abrasion and shoulder pressure. The designers also changed the waist of the suits so the astronauts could bend completely and seat on the rover.

The ‘backpacks’: the equipment the pilots carried on their backs were also redesigned to allow for longer walks on the Moon. They now carried more oxygen, more water, and had a longer battery life.

The suit and equipment weighed 500 lbs on Earth, and 80 lbs on the Moon. During the training on Earth the astronauts did wear the whole 500 lbs ensemble.

The rover: for this mission, NASA wanted a car that could roam the Moon’s surface. Boeing built three Lunar Roving Vehicles (LRV) for 40 million dollars -which was quite the price tag 50 years ago.

The rover weighted 460 lbs on Earth and could be folded. The terrain it was going to survey was rocky, so it had to be a 4-wheel drive. It looked a bit like the cars that are used to drive on desert dunes and it could achieve a 12 km/h speed (7.5 mi/h).

This was the first mission in which a rover was used, which allowed the astronauts to cover a lot more of terrain. Previously, the astronauts had only walked on the Moon, and covered about 3.5 km (2 mi) in each mission. In contrast, the Apollo 15 team covered 28 km (17.5 mi).

The rover did not return to Earth, the crew left it on the Moon.

Apollo 15 lands on the Moon

The 26 of July of 1971 the shuttle launched from the Kennedy Space Center at Merrit Island, Florida.

Four days later, the Apollo 15 was orbiting the Moon.

Then the Lunar Module (Falcon) detached from the Endeavor, in order to make its way to the Moon’s surface.

Back on Earth the astronauts had practiced the landing a thousand times. They had gone through every detail, even the landing hour had been scheduled so they would have the right light when approaching the site. But now their spacecraft’s exhaust was disturbing the Moon’s dust and between that and the mountain’s shadows, Scott and Irwin could not see the Moon’s surface clearly.

The result was a rough landing. Irwin has said that it was the roughest landing he had ever been in. And for a while, the two astronauts feared that their tilted vehicle would tip over.

They did not even land in the exact site they were supposed to, but 910 m (3,000 ft) away. Although it still was in the mountainous Hadley-Apennine region.

The Apollo 15’s moonwalks (EVAS)

Lunar surface. A suited astronaut from Apollo 15 drills the ground.
Scott drilling to get core samples and set some experiments. The astronauts had problems drilling, the soil was harder than they had anticipated. (Photo: NASA/Public domain)

Once they got everything under control, Commander Scott suited up and opened the hatch to take a good look of the Moon’s surface, like any good geologist would do. From the hatch he surveyed the terrain, took panoramic pictures, and described the landscape to Mission Control. That took 33 minutes.

The second day, July 31, both Scott and Irwin left the Falcon to explore the surface of the Moon and collected soil samples. But when Scott tried to drill the ground in order to set up an experiment, he was unsuccessful. The soil turned out to be a lot tougher than anyone had anticipated. Tired, he finally left the drill in its place and the astronauts returned to their ship. That first Extra Vehicular Activity (EVA), or spacewalk, lasted 6 hrs and 32 min.

The third day, they went out again, explored more craters and mountains, and Scott finished drilling. They returned to the Falcon after a 7 hrs and 12 min EVA.

Their last day, they spent most of their 4-hour EVA struggling again with the drill in order to break away a part of the Moon’s core. It took so long that they had to skip the other planned explorations. They did have time to pin the U.S. flag and take some pictures with it, though.

The 4 combined EVAS lasted 19 hours, that is 10 more hours than the spacewalks of the previous Apollo mission.

Read next: The feats These 3 Adventurers Accomplished Will Leave You Speechless

Science on the Moon

Apollo 15 was the first of the three “J Missions” to the Moon, which lasted longer and focused more on science.

These are some of the things the Apollo 15 crew did that made scientists happy:

Genesis rock: The Apollo explored the Apennine Mountains area because NASA believed it was on of the oldest places on the Moon, and that its soil could tell them about the Moon’s history.

There, on Spur Crater, Scott and Irwin picked up the small “Genesis Rock,” which is a an anorthosite, and probably was part of the Moon’s core.

And although at 4,1 billion years old it is a few centuries younger than the Moon, it has helped scientists understand the process of formation of the Moon.

The duo also collected 170 lbs (77 kg) worth of geological samples.

One for Galileo: In the 1500’s Italian scientist Galileo Galilei theorized that without air resistance, in a vacuum, two objects of a different weight would fall to the ground at the same speed. Some believe he even tried the experiment himself by climbing to the top of the Tower of Pisa and dropping two balls of different masses.

Since the astronauts were going to have the ideal vacuum conditions on the almost gravity-less Moon, they brought a hammer and a feather with them. Scott dropped them in front of the video camera that was transmitting live to Earth, and both objects did reach the ground at the same time, giving Galileo some late but due pat in the back.

Volcanic activity: while Worden orbited the Earth he took hundreds of pictures. Based on them, NASA saw that there probably was volcanic activity on an area of the Moon called Taurus-Littrow, and another mission, Apollo 17, was sent to investigate it.

Experiments Package: to learn more about the Moon’s environment, the Apollo 15 crew left a kit of instruments on its surface, the ALSEP, which collected data and transmitted it to Earth.

Moon subsatellite particles: shortly after leaving the Moon, the Falcon ejected this subsatellite so it would orbit the Moon. Originally, the plan was for it to stay in orbit for a year, but it malfunctioned after 6 months. Nevertheless, it accomplished what it was supposed to: it measured the magnetic fields of both Earth and Moon, the gravity field of the Moon, and the flux of protons and electrons.

The Endeavor orbits the Moon

While Scott and Irwin were on the Moon, Worden kept orbiting it. He was quite busy, working up to 18 hours a day, taking pictures, doing experiments, and exercising to keep his muscles from atrophying. He slept only about 4 hrs daily, for Al has said he was too excited to sleep.

Every time his shuttle orbited the far side of the Moon, he lost all communications with Earth.

Rendezvous: we meet again

Black space. A floating small spacecraft approaches. All that is seen from the Endeavor in the picture is a protruding metal tube.
The Falcon pictured from the Command/Service Module Endeavour during rendezvous. (Photo: NASA/Public domain)

On August 2 the Falcon left the Moon, and two hours later it met the orbiting Endeavor.

The Falcon had been on the Moon for 66 hours and 55 minutes, the longest time of any mission.

Once the two ships were rejoined and all astronauts were on the Endeavor, the Falcon was ejected and it crashed on the Moon’s surface.

The Endeavor was orbiting the Moon for the 74th time when it fired up to return home.

First deep-space walk in history

A fully suited Apollo 15 astronaut floats in space. He is connected to the spaceship next to him by a hose.
Al Worden floating in space while recovering the film cassettes. He was 315,000 km (196,000 mi) from Earth and far away from other celestial bodies. (Photo: NASA/Public domain)

Yet, there was one more EVA left, this time is was to take place in deep space. On August 5, Worden exited the spacecraft to collect film cassettes and the cameras.

They were 315,000 km (196,000 mi) from Earth and away from all other celestial bodies.

Worden has said he had trained so many times for it that he did it mechanically, and that he actually wished he had paused and appreciated the moment more.

His was the first deep-space EVA in history.

Worden was outside the shuttle for 39 minutes. Here is a short video of his stunt.

Apollo 15 reenters Earth with a splash

A few days later, on August 7, 1971, the Service Module was jettisoned so the Command Module could reenter the Earth’s atmosphere.

The Apollo landed at 15:45 (CDT), as planned, on the Pacific Ocean, north of Honolulu. Helicopters from the designated recovery ship, the USS Okinawa, flew to rescue the crew.

The Apollo 15 had been in space for 12 days and 7 hours.

Hiccups of the Apollo 15 mission

Even though 400,000 people worked to make Apollo 15’s voyage run smoothly, with a mission this complex – and in outer space- a thing or two were bound to go wrong.

Lunar surface. On the left is the lunar module which is a small spacecraft. On the right is an astronaut sitting on the rover.
Do notice the tilted Lunar Module on the left. Because of the tilt, the astronauts had a hard time detaching the rover from the Falcon. (Photo: NASA/Public domain)

Losing oxygen: Houston noticed that during the Falcon’s first night on the Moon’s surface the cabin was slowly loosing oxygen. Mission Control woke the astronauts one hour before the scheduled time to search for the leak. The culprit turned out to be a valve in the urination device that was not tightly closed.

The rover is stuck: When the astronauts went for their first moonwalk, they found out the rover was stuck to the Falcon because of the rough landing. After a few tries, they were able to detach it.

Three-wheel drive: Once the rover was on the floor, they realized one of the it’s front wheels was not working. Still, they managed to drive it that day. The next day the rover had reconsidered its tantrum and its four wheels were miraculously working again.

Heartbeat: during each of the three walks on the Moon, Houston noticed that Scott’s and Irwin’s heartbeats were irregular. Irwin probably had a mild heart attack on the way back to the Earth and died of another heart attack 20 years later.

Thirst: during the first moonwalk, Irwin’s water bag did not work, so he spent 7 hours without liquids.

Gadgets malfunction: Several of the instruments malfunctioned. A timer stopped on the way to the Moon, a panoramic camera was bugsy, and the spectrometer’s (a measuring instrument) components would not retract as they were supposed to.

One less parachute: After the spacecraft entered Earth’s atmosphere, the crew opened its three parachutes. But one opened only partially. Fortunately, the Apollo could safely land with 2.

Apollo 15’s controversies

Smuggled envelopes

The three astronauts made a lucrative deal with a German stamp dealer by the name of Herman Sieger, who asked them to take 100 stamped envelopes (called ‘covers’ by collectors) to the Moon.

A common white envelope. It has three Apollo-related stamps, a NASA seal which includes the names of the three Apollo 15 astronauts, and it is signed by the Scott, Worden, and Irwin.
The astronauts took 100 unauthorized envelopes to the Moon in exchange for 21,000 dollars. NASA was no happy with their entrepreneurial spirit. Pictured one of the controversial envelopes. (Photo: Heritage auctions/Public domain)

The envelopes, which were not disclosed to NASA, were date-stamped in the postal service both on the day the Apollo launched and the day it returned. And they were on the Falcon when it landed on the Moon.

Each of the astronauts made 7,500 dollars with the deal. And they were so inspired by Sieger’s idea, that they took 300 extra envelopes on the voyage, 100 a head, to sell them themselves.

Apparently, the dealer had promised Scott, Irwin, and Worden that he would not sell the covers until the Apollo program had shut down -which would take years. In turn, he sold them within months for 150,000 dollars.

Word got to the press, and NASA was not happy. The astronauts were called to explain themselves in the Senate while NASA reprimanded them for “poor judgement” and took them off the Apollo 17 mission, for which they were the backup crew.

The trio never flew to space again, although they remained in NASA for a few more years in managerial positions.

Figurine
A close up of the lunar surface. On the ground lies a small plaque with written names. Next to it is a small figurine that resembles a human-shaped robot.
The plaque and tiny figurine Scott left on the Moon’s surface to honor the fallen cosmonauts. (Photo: NASA/Public domain)

Unlike the previous fiasco, this one stayed mostly out of the papers.

Scott wanted to honor the 14 Soviet and American cosmonauts that had died on space missions. So he asked Belgian artist Paul Van Hoeydonck to anonymously make a 3.5 inch figurine that represented them, and Scott himself designed a small plaque which bore the 14 names.

He got NASA’s authorization for taking both pieces to space with him. And during one of the moonwalks, he quietly left them on the lunar surface.

According to Scott, this was supposed to be a low-profile homage.

But Van Hoeydonck, the artist, remembered things differently. He said he never agreed to remain anonymous, and he wanted to make and sell 950 copies of the figurine, which Scott had named Fallen Astronaut.

Nonetheless, NASA rained on his parade and, under pressure, Van Hoeydonck backtracked from the sale.

Related Posts

2020-04-26
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments